Renting against buying

Buying is not automatically better than renting. The honest comparison is the total cost of owning, including interest, taxes, insurance, maintenance and the transaction costs at both ends, against rent plus whatever the down payment would have earned invested.

Time horizon usually decides it. Buying and selling a house costs roughly 8 to 10 percent of the price in fees between them, which takes several years of appreciation to recover.

Common questions

How long do I need to stay for buying to win?

Commonly five years or more, though it depends on the local price to rent ratio and what your down payment would have earned elsewhere. Below about three years the transaction costs alone usually make renting cheaper.

Is rent really throwing money away?

No more than mortgage interest, property tax, insurance and maintenance are. In the early years of a mortgage the large majority of each payment is interest rather than equity, so the amount of a payment that actually builds wealth is smaller than it feels.

What is the price to rent ratio?

Purchase price divided by a year of rent for a similar property. Under about 15 buying tends to look favourable, over about 21 renting usually does, and the middle is genuinely a judgement call that depends on how long you stay.

Does buying protect me from rising rents?

Partly. A fixed rate mortgage payment does not rise, which is real protection, but property taxes, insurance and maintenance all track inflation and have risen sharply in many states.

Related calculators